Should You Repair Your Roof Or Replace It? Your Roofing Guide

June 21, 2022

If you've noticed some missing tiles on your roof, your metal roof is leaking or your tiled roof has been damaged due to bad weather, you might be wondering whether it is better to repair or replace your roof. Roof issues can be costly and deciding which is the best course of action depends on the condition of your roof. In this roofing guide, we take a look at the different types of roof damage, signs your roof needs replacing and whether you should repair or replace your roof.

Table of contents:

Signs your Roof needs Attention
Should you Replace or Repair your Roof?
The Extent of the Damage
The Quality of the Roof
The Age of the Roof
The Cost of the Work
Protecting your Home
Call the Experts

Signs your Roof needs Attention

Roof issues can be costly and also lead to further damage like damp and mould, so action is needed as soon as possible. If you think your roof might need repairing or replacing, it's important to look out for these signs of roof deterioration:

leaks or puddles of water
storm damage
holes or gaps in the roof
missing tiles
increased heating bills
moss growth

Should you Replace or Repair your Roof?

There are several factors to consider when deciding whether to replace a roof or repair it. If you are concerned about the condition of the roof on your property, you can also hire a professional to carry out a thorough roof inspection and report before you decide what to do.

In general, the following factors should be considered when making a decision about roof repair or replacement:

The Extent of the Damage

If sections of your roof have been torn off in a storm or you can see daylight through the gaps in your roof, it's probably more economical to replace your entire roof than pay for numerous repairs. Choosing the best roofing for high winds also means your home should have more protection in the future from bad weather conditions. If you only have slight damage to your roof, like a dent in a metal roof or a missing tile, it might be worth getting your roof repaired as it is far cheaper than getting a completely new roof installed.

The Quality of the Roof

Poor-quality roofing installation is another reason that roofs degrade over time, as are below-standard materials. If you've had any concerns about the quality of your roof and it has been damaged, a replacement could be a good investment for your property. If you have an old tile roof which has been having repeated issues, it could be a good idea to replace it with a new Colorbond roof. There are a number of ways Colorbond roofing outperforms tile roofing, including reduced maintenance, added durability and corrosion resistance.

The Age of the Roof

It's also important to think about how old your roof is and whether it's nearly time for a replacement anyway. A Colorbond roof can last up to 70 years with minimal maintenance and most tile roofs are expected to last around 60 years. Check when your roof was installed and how long it is until you will need to replace it and then you can decide whether it's worth doing the work now. If your roof is relatively new and just has some minor damage that can be repaired, it probably isn't worth replacing the whole thing.

The Cost of the Work

Another important factor in any roofing decision is the cost of the project. If the damage to your roof has been severe, repair work might cost as much, if not more than a replacement, especially if the area is hard to access. If repair costs are going to be more than half the cost of replacement, it could be worth considering a new roof as it will also have a warranty and be more resistant to future damage. However, if you can find an affordable roof repair & maintenance company, they will be able to tell you how much both jobs will cost and which is more economical in the long-term.

Protecting your Home

Roofs are designed to last for many years, but it's crucial that they are maintained correctly and kept in good condition. This includes clearing gutters, cleaning off moss and inspecting your roof regularly for signs of damage. It's important to repair any roof issues as soon as possible and make a note of how often you are having to have your roof repaired. If your roof constantly needs fixing, it could be a good idea to replace it with a better quality roof like a Colorbond metal roof. Replacing a damaged roof with a brand new metal roof can also improve the look of your property and add value.

Call the Experts

If you need a roof repair or roof replacement in Townsville, Top to Bottom Plumbing can install a high-quality Colorbond roof that will last for decades. Call our roofing experts today on 07 4779 7722 and they can inspect your roof and determine whether replacement or repair is the best course of action.

< Older Post Newer Post >

Roofing Issues? Here’s How the Pros Fix Them

By Top To Bottom Plumbing • July 29, 2025

Roofing Issues? Here’s How the Pros Fix Them When it comes to protecting a property, the roof is the first line of defence against the elements. Yet many property owners overlook the importance of timely maintenance and repairs until small issues become major headaches. Whether you’re a homeowner or running a business, addressing roofing problems early can prevent costly damage to interiors, structural elements, and personal belongings. Professional roofing services don’t just patch holes—they deliver thorough assessments, quality materials, and skilled workmanship to keep roofs safe, functional, and looking their best. In this blog post, we’ll explore a few common roofing issues and how roofers tackle them. Leaky Roofs: Why Professional Repairs Are Essential A leaking roof is one of the most common—and damaging—issues a property can face. Even small leaks can cause structural damage, mould, and stained ceilings. Because water often travels before appearing indoors, it’s important to have a professional accurately find and repair the true source. Professional roofers take a thorough approach to ensure leaks are properly resolved: Locate hidden entry points using inspection tools. Replace damaged flashings or tiles that allow water to enter. Apply high-quality sealants and membranes to restore watertight protection. With expert repairs, a leaking roof can be transformed from a persistent problem into a reliable shield against the elements. Storm Damage Assessment: Restoring Safety & Integrity Severe weather can batter roofs with high winds, hail, and torrential rain, often leaving behind obvious and hidden damage that threatens a building’s integrity. Even minor storm impacts can create weaknesses that lead to serious problems if left unaddressed, including leaks, mould, and structural instability. Professionals know what to look for after a storm to catch damage early and prevent further issues: Inspect for lifted or missing tiles and metal sheeting. Check seals and flashings for breaks that let water in. Assess structural damage or weakened roof trusses. Thorough post-storm assessments help document damage for insurance claims, prioritise urgent repairs, and ensure the roof is restored to provide reliable protection for occupants and their belongings. Dealing with Rusted or Corroded Metal Roofing Metal roofing is known for its durability and long lifespan, but it’s not immune to corrosion, especially in areas exposed to salt air or high humidity. Over time, rust can develop and spread if left untreated, weakening roof sheets, compromising fixings, and eventually leading to leaks or structural failure. Professionals provide tailored solutions to address corrosion effectively: Inspect for rust spread and depth of damage. Treat minor rust with anti-corrosion coatings. Replace severely corroded sheets or fasteners. Sagging Roof Structures: Hidden Dangers Uncovered A sagging roof isn’t just unsightly—it’s a warning sign of serious underlying problems. Possible causes include water damage weakening timber supports, structural overload, or long-term neglect. Left unaddressed, sagging can lead to partial collapse. Professionals approach this carefully: Conduct detailed inspections to assess the extent and cause. Replace or reinforce damaged structural components. Ensure repairs meet all building standards for safety. Comprehensive structural repairs restore the roof’s appearance and integrity, helping ensure the building remains safe and secure well into the future. Blocked or Damaged Roof Gutters & Drainage Systems Roof drainage is often overlooked until problems become impossible to ignore. Blocked or damaged gutters and downpipes can cause water to overflow in the wrong places, damaging fascia boards, walls, and even the foundations of a building. Overflowing water can also lead to unsightly stains and encourage mould growth around the home. Professional roofing services ensure: Thorough cleaning of gutters and downpipes to restore flow. Repairs or replacements for cracked, rusted, or sagging sections. Recommendations for guards or regular maintenance schedules. Reliable gutter maintenance and repairs help prevent costly water damage and ensure the entire roof drainage system stays effective in all weather conditions. Poor Roof Ventilation & Its Impact on Your Home Roof ventilation is critical for managing heat and moisture in roof spaces. Without adequate ventilation, a home can experience excessive heat buildup in summer, condensation issues in winter, and accelerated deterioration of roofing materials. Over time, poor ventilation can also contribute to mould growth and higher energy costs as heating and cooling systems work harder. Professionals assess existing ventilation and offer tailored solutions such as: Installing ridge vents, whirlybirds, or eaves vents to encourage natural airflow. Balancing ventilation to prevent moisture build-up that can damage insulation and structural components. Providing advice on best practices for maintaining energy efficiency and indoor comfort. Properly designed and installed ventilation improves comfort year-round and helps extend the lifespan of the roof by reducing heat stress and moisture-related damage. Ageing & Weathered Roofing Materials: When to Replace All roofing materials deteriorate over time due to constant exposure to sun, wind, rain, and temperature changes. Older roofs can develop issues like cracked or broken tiles, faded or corroded metal sheets, or weakened underlays without reliable protection. Professionals help determine when repairs are no longer enough and replacement is the better option: Detailed inspections to evaluate overall condition. Advice on the remaining lifespan and risks of delaying replacement. Planning re-roofing projects that improve protection and add value. Roofers specialise in delivering safe, efficient roof replacements using durable, high-quality materials designed to withstand harsh weather and extend the life of the roof for years. The Value of Professional Roof Inspections & Maintenance Preventive maintenance is far more cost-effective than emergency repairs after a failure. Regular professional inspections catch small problems before they escalate, helping property owners avoid unexpected disruptions and expensive damage. Professional maintenance typically includes: Checking for loose or broken tiles, flashings, and ridge caps that can let water in or be dislodged in high winds. Inspecting sealants and joints for signs of cracking or wear that compromise waterproofing. Clearing gutters and drains to prevent blockages that cause water to overflow and damage walls or foundations. Assessing overall roof condition to identify early signs of ageing, corrosion, or structural movement. Offering expert recommendations for repairs, upgrades, or future maintenance to keep the roof performing its best. Protect Your Property with Expert Roofing in Townsville At Top to Bottom Plumbing, we know a roof is more than just shelter—it’s peace of mind for your family or business. Our roofers in Townsville deliver thorough inspections, reliable repairs, and quality installations tailored to the local environment. If you’ve noticed leaks, storm damage, rust, sagging, or other roofing issues, don’t wait for them to worsen. Get in touch via our contact page to learn more about our services.